Saturday, February 28, 2015

Nancy 1.0 and the Book

In light of Nancy recently reaching 1.0 (and quickly thereafter 1.1), I thought it was appropriate to revisit my Nancy book, and the running code sample in it on Nancy 1.1. This post looks at what's changed and what I might have coded differently now.

But first,

Is the Book still Relevant?

Yes, I think the book is still relevant. Almost all the code works unchanged with Nancy 1.1, and Nancy still follows the same principals and philosophy. I still think the book is a quick way to get introduced to Nancys way of doing things, the DSLs it provides and it awesome extensibility.
(But then again, I may be slightly biased)

What Broke Between Then and Now?

After updating the Nancy packages in my copy of the code for the 12th and final chapter of the book only one thing did not compile. One method on the IBodyDeserializer interface has changes, namely CanDeserialize which now receives a BindingContext as an argument. I added this argument, compiled and all tests passed and AFAICT everything worked.
That's it. And that says a lot about Nancy. There may not be a lot of promises of backward compatibility, but still the effort needed to update from 0.17 to 1.1 was minimal.

I have had comments that the MongoDB driver used is out of date and that the code in the book uses methods from it that are now obsolete. Since MongoDB is not the subject of the book and the code still works, I'm going to continue punting on that one, and just say no big deal.

What Would I Have Done Differently?


The book covers ASP.NET hosting and self hosting and how to setup a solution where the site is in a class library which can be re-used across hosts. Today I might still start out with the ASP.NET host because it is familiar to many ASP.NET developers, but self hosting as well as the cross host scenario would be OWIN based. In general I'd recommend OWIN hosting now, so that would have some space in the book, if written today.

The Cloud Chapter

Hmmm. Deploying Nancy to the cloud. That chapter seemed like a good idea up front. But wasn't. It ended up being more about some esotric xUnit setup stuff than about deployment. Why? Because deploying Nancy to the cloud is no big deal. It's just like deploying any ASP.NET (or OWIN) application to the cloud. In other words nothing special.
I didn't see that while writing, though, but I hope I would have left this chapter out if I'd written the book today. Maybe a chapter on OWIN would have been a better idea.


The book describes adding Tiwtter login using the Worlddomination NuGet packages. Unfortunately that package changed it's name to SimpleAuthentication between my final draft and the publication of the book. Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.
In any case, if writing the book today I think I would have pushed the Twitter authentication down to the OWIN level. On the other hand that would mean less focus on Nancy and more on OWIN. But I think that is what I'd do, because using OWIN middleware for authentication would be my (general) recommendation today.

Test Defaults

I worte the book in a test first fashion - showing tests first and then implementation. I'm still happy with that decision, because it emphasizes the awesome Nancy.Testing library and just how testable Nancy is. -And for me testability is a major feature of a framework.
There is a feature that has been introduced in Nancy since the book was written that would have allowed me to cut down on a lot of duplication in the test code, namely defaults for the Browser object. I would have used that all over the book if writing it now, and highly recommend using the Browser defaults.


This is minor, but if writing the book today I would not have used NLog but SeriLog instead.

No comments:

Post a Comment